we asked if Mahi Mahi was possible and we were told yes. but the day before we went we were told the current was wrong and it would be lucky to catch Mahi Mahi or tuna. maybe catch a sail fish but our boat didn’t have the true sail fish set up. Captain did his best and the first mate worked very hard the whole time. We went to another spot at the end of our time and both captain and mate got us on some fish for our dinner.  The captain did a beautiful job cleaning them and he was friendly and kind. the first mate is arrogant or didn’t want to be there. he was excellent at his fishing skills but his social skills leave much to be desired. 4 hours of one word answers is a bit much. and then when he but our head off because our tip wasn’t good enough was enough for me to think I needed to warn other people. at 45 years old he should know how to let people know what he expects for a tip rather than be aggressive after he sees the amount isn’t right. the Captain told us what the right amount was so we gave it to him.