Had an absolute blast with Captain Teddy.  From prebooking through fish cleaning, he was on top of his game and communicated well every step of the way.  He put us on the fish immediately and my boys had a blast hauling out fish after fish.  Lines snagged in the rock and lost bait were never and issue and he had us all fishing all the time.  His boat is immaculate and well maintained and he kept everything neat and tidy throughout the trip.  Consummate professional. Highly recommend

Great time! Highly recommend this to anyone. Took care of everything and extremely knowledgeable about the entire trip. He is a fourth generation who knows what he’s doing! First time deep sea fishing for a couple of us and it was perfect for all fishing levels! Weather was perfect with 2 foot waves. Caught Mahi-Mahi, Barracuda , and 10 tunas in 6 hours. Just an FYI, we gave some fish fillets away cause we caught so much and people were very appreciative but Anthony’s (right next to Atlantis) restaurant and the Poop Deck (by the boat dock) will cook it for $19-$20 per person. We did Anthony’s and they cooked it perfect and side dishes were included in the price. Would do it again with my brother, son (20), and nephews (16,12). Loved it!

First of all Teddy was amazing.. great communication.. messages back immediately! We were worried about weather etc.. also not knowing the charter.  Boys fish allot and gave Teddy rave reviews!!!!  Professional with over 30 years of experience!! Caught mahi mahi and black fin tuna:-) got it cooked up at the poop deck next door:-))  we will definitely call him again when back! book him!!!

We specifically wanted to target wahoo and another Captin on fishing booker recommended captain Teddy. Teddy went above and beyond to make sure that we caught wahoo, including adjusting our pick up time, helping with transportation and getting us out to the area where he knew would be wahoo. He’s a great guy with generational knowledge about the island and it’s waters. We caught two wahoo in 2 1/2 hours (25-30 pound and 35-40 pounds).

Book Teddy if you’re serious about fishing and are looking for an expert!

Great day out with Captain Teddy.  His boat is immaculate.  He had all the correct bait and fishing techniques to show my son and I a great day of fishing.  Looking forward to eating the snapper and grouper that we caught.  Highly recommend.